Many writers stick to summarizing ones words over quoting them. Commenting and building off others with summarized ideas are essential for making a sound argument but. The art of quoting a quote is the use of an outside sources exact words in an essay, enclosed in quotation marks, to support or clarify the writers ideas. The quote sandwich adapted from they say i say, pp. They say i say shows that writing well means mastering some key rhetorical moves, the most important of which involves summarizing what others have said they say to set up ones own argument i say. As he himself puts it the art of quoting leave a reply cancel reply. You need to write the arguments of others into your text. Sep 16, 20 chapter three of they say, i say illustrates the best way to take word for word quotes and plug them into your own text.
Start a free trial of quizlet plus by thanksgiving lock in 50% off all year try it free. Citation graff, gerald, cathy birkenstein and russel durst. However, there are other ways of incorporating what others are saying. The art of quoting folsom cordova unified school district.
The authors identify the key rhetorical moves in academic writing, showing students how to frame their arguments in the larger context of what others have said and providing templates to help them make those moves. They sayi say pages 115 posted on february 3, 2016 february 12, 2016 by alyssahinkle within the first few pages of they say i say by gerald graff and cathy birkenstein, it is clear what this book is aiming to do for your writing abilities. Quoting or using quotations is the most common form of incorporating evidence into your writing. They say i say chapter three as he himself puts it the art. This chapter explains how to write the text of your paper. I didnt even know what metacommentary was before reading this book, but i use it a lot now. It is a practical book that demystifies academic writing through the provision of basic templates that help firstyear college students grasp the structure of good academic argument.
A direct quotation is used to support your claims or. So while part 1 addresses the art of listening to others, part 2 addresses how to offer ones own response. Champion of the world maya angelou why sports matter wilfrid sheed women who hit very hard and how they ve changed tennis michael kimmelman in defense of cheering jennie yabroff how i learned to love football felisa rogers move over boys, make room in the crease sara maratta we, the public, place the best. In a sense, they say i say is a variation on the my fair lady plot. As he himself puts itart of quoting when writing essays, reports or any writing type, it is best to use the arguements or phrases used by other authors or writers, not just only by summarising their piece of work, but by quoting their sentences or phrases using the precise words used. Mar 21, 2014 they say i say summarizing and quoting tips jilljitsu81. Sep 05, 2016 chapter 1 they say starting with what others are saying summary. Most writers write summaries incorrectly because they either put too much of their own input, or talk about the authors ideas. They state the importance of summarizing others work but having it tie in with your own ideas. Her point is the art of summarizing if itis t rue, as we claim in this book. One of the best ways to do so is by not only summarizing what they say as suggested in chapter two, but by quoting their exact words. This oer repository is a collection of free resources provided by equella.
The moves that matter in academic writing this chapter explains how to write the text of your paper. Sep 23, 20 this chapter explains how to write the text of your paper. Chapter 3 as he himself puts it the art of quoting sema. The point we want to emphasize is that quoting what they say must always be connected with what you say. We tend to think of argument as something abstract and global but, in. In fact, aligning what they say with what you say is a good thing. In fact, aligning what they saywith what you say isagood thing. The authors offer a clear and useful template approach to constructing academic arguments in several disciplines, on the premise that all good academic writing forms part of the stream of intellectual discourse the they say to which a writer adds her or his i say. The moves that matter in academic writing third edition 3rd edition by gerald graff author, cathy birkenstein aut. Graff and birkenstien point out the common errors made in quoting. The chapters i have highlighted in these reading notes could possibly be used in a short course on academic writing based on the they sayi say model, although an instructor may want to also add the but dont get me wrong the art of metacommentary chapter 10, p. Chapter 5 and yet in writing it is important to differentiate the various perspectives that may be presented and to be able to pick them out to indicate whose voice the writer is speaking in. I need to emphasize on what interested me the most from the author, but also not change what they said.
Quoting exact words from other people is the best way to launch an effective argument because it gives credibility to your summary. In the second chapter of they say i say graff and birkenstein discuss the art of summarizing. Choosing quotes wisely will be play a big role in supporting what you have written. When using quotations it is important to build a frame around them with your own words to keep them. Specifically, graff and birkenstein argue that the types of writing templates they offer practice abstract principles of writing. Starting with what others are saying two her point is 30. The art of summarizing the art of quoting yes, no, ok, but. Think of them as moves in a video game or a sportthe better we get at the game or sport, the more comfortable we get with knowing when and how to use a move best. Dave cannot respond to share requests my apologies. The book they say, i say is the book i wish i had had at the beginning of my own graduate studies. The moves that matter in academic writing with readings.
Chapter 3 as he himself puts it the art of quoting. Sep 16, 20 they say i say chapter 2, the art of summarizing posted on september 16, 20 by maybellepulgarin chapter two explains very deeply on how to write a good summary. Explore they say quotes by authors including william shakespeare, ronald reagan, and plato at brainyquote. Quoting anothers words give you a lot of creditability to your. They say i say shows that writing well means mastering some key rhetorical moves, the most important of which involves summarizing what others have said they say to set up one s own argument i say. Specifically, graff and birkenstein argue that the types of writing templates they offer practice abstract principles. Subchapter 3 the art of quoting posted on september 23, 20 by maybellepulgarin in response to exercise number two, i pulled out some old essays ive written in other classes. One of the best ways to write an argument into a text is by not only summarizing what they say. Subsequent chapters take up the arts of summarizing and quoting what these others have to say. The main idea in chapter 3 is art of quoting quoting someone elses words can give you a chance to assure its fair and detailed. The art of summarizing, the art of quoting, distinguishing what you say from what they say, planting a naysayer in your text, connecting the parts, and the art of metacommentary. They say i say summarizing and quoting tips youtube.
Sep 01, 2005 they say i say shows that writing well means mastering some key rhetorical moves, the most important of which involves summarizing what others have said they say to set up ones own argument i say. Its important that i understand what the author said so that i wont make the mistake of. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. In the first chapter of they say, i say by authors graff and birkenstein the authors start off the chapter by explaining the beneficial outcome of the writer or reader starting with what others say. The authors start by giving a small thought about the art of summarizing, why people do it and why others despise this way of writing. To have an effective argument of your own, you must learn how to include arguments of others into your paper first. Three ways to respond distinguishing what you say from what they say planting a naysayer in your text saying why it matters connecting the parts each short chapter describes relevant argumentative moves, provides amusing and insightful examples. Chapter two explains very deeply on how to write a good summary. Dont throw quotes in here and there just to have quotes. I didnt even know what metacommentary was before reading this book, but. I say 53 four yes no okay, but 55 three ways to respond five and yet 68 distinguishing what you say from what they say. Her point is the art of summarizing 18 sep 20 leave a comment. The moves that matter in academic writing by john edlund when you assign research papers and other academic writing that uses sources, do you get papers in which it is hard to tell who is saying what. Mar 30, 2011 as he himself puts it art of quoting when writing essays, reports or any writing type, it is best to use the arguements or phrases used by other authors or writers, not just only by summarising their piece of work, but by quoting their sentences or phrases using the precise words used.
Gerald graffs most popular book is the adventures of huckleberry finn. Gerald graff has 63 books on goodreads with 14701 ratings. Preface to they say i say 0 general document comments 0 sentence and paragraph comments. The art of summarizing animated by the writers own interests, they often read like mere. Its not only about summarizing what they say, but quoting their exact words. They say 17 one they say 19 starting with what others are saying two her point is 30 the art of summarizing three as he himself puts it 42 the art of quoting part 2. The author suggests two possibilities for why writers overquote. Unfortunately, not all students take this art so seriously 4. The art of quoting the art of quoting what is quoting. They say starting with what others are saying next chapter 3. Fountain in fact dada works of art were rejected by most critics. We tend to think of argument as something abstract and global but, in reality, concrete strategies like framing quotations can make a big difference in the overall. The bestselling book that demystifies academic writing, they say i say, the moves that matter in academic writing, gerald graff, cathy birkenstein.
Choose your quotations wisely and make sure they are relevant and quoting what they say must always be connected with what you say. With that said, play around with these, notice how they are used in the writings of others. Graff and birkenstein argue that to write a summary, the author has to isolate his or her thoughts and try to express the actual essence of the piece of writing they. We will be reading several excerpts from this book.
Chapter three of they say, i say illustrates the best way to take word for word quotes and plug them into your own text. In other words, the work you engage in and produce at the university will. Quoting is word for word or verbatim, relevant and usually brief, introduced or framed by your writing, in quotation marks block quoting requires different formatting, and needs attribution and citation. The use of a quote can lend credibility to your summaries and ensure that you are using the source fairly and accurately. Nov 09, 2010 now lets move on to chapter 3 which is called the art of quoting. The art of summarizing three as he himself puts it 42. Terms in this set 24 to write an effective argument. Subchapter 3 the art of quoting posted on september 23, 20 by maybellepulgarin in response to exercise number two, i pulled. The bestselling new composition book published in this century, they say i say has essentially defined academic writing, identifying its key rhetorical moves, the most important of which is to summarize what others have said they say to set up ones own argument i say. Quoting someone else gives your own writing more credibility. In chapter 2, her point is, of the book they say, i say, by gerald graff and cathy birkenstein the main argument is the guide to a good summary. It proves someone else agrees with you in your argument.
The seconds step is to make their relevance present. Also by surrounding major quotations with a frame, you are explaining whose words they are and how the quote relates with your work. When in quoting always make sure what you want do to with them, thats how they will support your visual text. The art of quoting beginning composition a focus on style adapted from graff, gerald and cathy birkenstein. In addition to explaining the basic moves, this book provides writing templates that show students explicitly how to make these moves in their own writing.
The thing that alarms me is that there are so many clergymen who say that the socalled new morality is all right. The moves that matter in academic writing chapter questions these questions can be answered after completing each of the chapters we have pulled from the fourth edition 2018 of they say, i say, by gerald graff and cathy birkenstein. They say, i say ch 3as he himself puts it orthe art of quoting 2. Such writers fail to see that quoting means more than sim ply enclosing what they say in quotation markis. They sayi say is, i think, the best college writing guide. They say i say chapter three as he himself puts it the art of quoting paragraph 1 1. The moves that matter in academic writing, gerald graff and cathy birkenstein provide templates designed to educate persuasive writing. Summarizing, quoting, responding 3 pages english homework help. Now lets move on to chapter 3 which is called the art of quoting. By teaching students to reduce every argument down to a singleissue conflict, graff and birkenstein inherently limit the possible insights that a writer can.
This passage explains all of the fundamentals of quoting text in your writing. They say i say summarizing and quoting tips jilljitsu81. It lists out, step by step and rules to follow to keep you on track and make sure youre quoting correctly. Introduction know where you are going list summaries in order to make effective arguments, we must be able to summarize the claims of others effectively. Im the one person who wears the words hustle, loyalty, respect on my tshirts and merchandise. Voice markers, as they are often called, are used to distinguish between various perspectives in texts. One sentence summary there are many strategies to summarizing an authors writing. One way to do this is through summary, which is putting into your own words what someone else is saying. Academic writing requires presenting your sources and your ideas effectively to readers.
In 1917, he inverted a urinal, signed it with a false name, called it fountain and sent it to an exhibition. In this chapter, the authors paint a picture of the importance of the order of what things are said. Sep 28, 2016 in chapter 2, her point is, of the book they say, i say, by gerald graff and cathy birkenstein the main argument is the guide to a good summary. Yesit is an art to quote others in a way that it helps not hurts. If i could say it in words there would be no reason to paint. Your quote should support the topic you are currently discussing. Theyve incorporated the quote, but the quote isnt explained.